It seems to me that music is key to my psyche.  The thing that gets me started.  I’m sure there are other things out there, but nothing really opens the door to my mind like music.

I recently had the opportunity to share some of my musical pleasures.  It’s nice to share that.

The other day I was listening to music and one of my favorite songs rotated into play on the iPod.  I have to say – the music is OK, but the lyrics are something very wonderful.  I don’t really understand how musicians can use random words and phrases to create completely unique messages that seem to make sense.  I guess it’s a talent I lack, but not one I’m terribly worried about.

So, this song.  It’s called “A Thousand Days”.  I have always liked it, but it seems to have more significance now.  Let’s give it a read, shall we?

I can’t remember, the way you carried your name.
I had a snapshot that I discarded out of pride or shame.
“Time to talk it out, turn the thing about,” So I’ve been told.
I’ve taken such advice, at first it sounded nice, but now its getting old.

I called you at your lover’s home today, I felt that I should try.
That’s the voice it takes to stay my faith, somewhere inside.
How I wonder, how I wonder sometimes.

I can’t remember, which one of us was to blame.
The years surrender, to one September with a thousand days.
“Keep your chin up son, your day is sure to come,” these weary words.
Emptying my glass, I wait for it to pass as the picture blurs.

I drove by your family’s home today, and saw your child cry.
Held in our embrace, you dried his face, tight by your side.
How I wonder, How I wonder what you are.

Take the time to talk, Give it one more shot, or so I hear.
I’m not certain that I’m right,
but I’ve been putting up this fight for too many years.

I call you at your family’s home at night and sometimes wonder why,
I can’t seem to break this senseless faith in something gone by.
How I wonder, How I wonder sometimes.

How soon will we be alone again?
I’ll take you, take you for everything.
Don’t shout, the children are sleeping still.
We’ll wake together I know we will.
How I wonder, How I wonder sometimes.

So, I used to think it’s a song about love gone sour.  A break-up from long ago – a person yearning to get it back.  Now, I’m not so sure.

I’ve always been fond of the following passage:

I drove by your family’s home today, and saw your child cry.
Held in our embrace, you dried his face, tight by your side.
How I wonder, How I wonder what you are.

It seems like something that has happened.  Like the author has experienced pain and heartbreak.  Like a love long lost.  It seems very meaningful.

But then I began to think more and more about some of the other words.

How soon will we be alone again?
I’ll take you, take you for everything.
Don’t shout, the children are sleeping still.
We’ll wake together I know we will.
How I wonder, How I wonder sometimes.

So, it is about love lost, or an affair – forbidden love?  “How soon will we be alone again?”  As if an intense love burns brightly within, but has no escape.  No way to be shown.  A love that should be shown.

“We’ll wake together I know we will.”  A choice.  The choice of believing that things will work out.  The choice of knowing that although now she might be holding her child in a tight embrace, that some day she might be holding someone else.  That the sun will dawn with her near.  That the tight embrace can comfort more than a small child.  That you will know how she is.  That you help her be well.  That you are well because she is near.

And there are more song – songs from the same band.  Here are a few short passages that I find interesting in this context.

Tomorrow I will be waking
I feel the pleasure of pleasing recede
I watch my hands begin shaking

I know I’ll go when you call
I wish I could resist the fall

I’ll go when you call me.
We know that we both belong here.
I trust there’s nothing wrong,
Your conscience clear
Your conscience clear

The guilt of an affair?  Seems so.

And this:

Stephen hands her a comb and brush. She preens her hair.
Glancing sideways, she believes she’s suspended in mid air.

Do you love me? Yes, I love you like I’ll never love again.
Will you leave me? Yes, I’ll leave you to be loved by other men.

Please stand up. Please be good enough to turn around.
Keep your lips open, knees apart, eyes fixed on the ground.

Do you love me? Yes, I love you like the marks upon your skin.
Will you leave me? Yes, I’ll leave you in the hands of other men.

She never wants to say goodbye.
She tries, but she never wants to say goodbye.

And all at once it all starts spinning round her head.
Somehow, something seemed to be so clear.
She holds her breath now just because she thinks she can.
As if on this point she might make a stand.

What I find fascinating about these lyrics is the dichotomy.  Yes he loves her.  Yes he will leave her.  Perhaps the love of a father for his daugther? That he must let her go so she can know true love?  I don’t know.

It also has one of my most favorite quotes of all:

She holds her breath now just because she thinks she can.
As if on this point she might make a stand.

I don’t know what this has to do with the rest of the song, but I just like it.  She does it just because she can.

It seems to me the author is racked with quilt – guilt about an affair, guilt about letting love go, guilt about not capturing the most important moments of life.  Or regretting watching some of them pass by – right there in front of his eyes.

Perhaps my analysis of the words is not accurate.  Perhaps it means none of this.  But it doesn’t matter, because it means all those things to me.  Which brings me to my life lesson for today.  Having that which is forbidden.

There was a time when things were just black and white.  I’ve always been a clear, direct, and black and white person.  It has benefited me, and dogged me my entire life.  Over the last year I’ve come to realize that every situation is clouded by gray.  Even the most honest, concise, and patently obvious situations are marred by the unyielding conscience of human existence.  Humans you see, are non-deterministic.  They are random.  They are not predicable.

Some people exercise their randomness with acts of kindness and beauty.  Some don’t.  Some people can’t seem to tell the truth. Some people make sure the truth is farthest from the most important thing they are interested in.  But none of that is the point of this story.

The point is – what is really forbidden?  I used to think if a person has an affair, and then ends up with the person they had an affair with, would both of them wonder if it could happen again?  If you had an affair once, what’s to stop you from doing it again?  Would there always be that sense of caution and distrust – because you know what the other person is capable of.  Perhaps.

But, perhaps the affair happened for a reason.  Perhaps once it happens, you know what to look for.  The signs.  Perhaps when things go awry, it’s more noticeable and easier to mend?  Perhaps you know how to mend the situation – or admit more easily that it can’t be mended?

Perhaps the new relationship is more solid because of a shared experience.  The experience of a failed relationship?  Failure, it seems, may bond.  There is a common ground there, that without knowing of its existence, makes the current situation acceptable.  But once you know something is there – the situation becomes less tolerable.  Less acceptable.  It opens a desire to fix it – in which ever way makes most sense.

I don’t know the answer to any of these questions, but some how the knowledge that there is another side to every story; that people do things because it makes sense; because it may be better for everyone is some consolation.  It’s not rationalization – it is a perspective I have gained.  A new and unique perspective that has been filtering a lot of what I see and do these days.  It has had a positive impact on my life.  It has helped me understand more about human actions and behaviors than I have in the past.  It makes me appreciate the gray – perhaps one day I’ll embrace it.

All of this has made me wonder if I have been living a lie? Is staying together just to avoid hurting a child the right answer?  Can you avoid hurting a child and still do the right thing?  Is it unfair to everyone to continue avoiding the truth?  The things you both know are there, but don’t talk about?

It’s not about someone else; it does not matter how you’ve arrived at the understanding.

The truth is the truth.  It’s about you; it’s about me.  It’s not selfish or self-serving.  It seems selfish to me to continue without change.  It seems lazy.  It seems easy.  A cop out.

I fear the unknown.  Don’t fear the unknown.

It seems to me that happiness should not be forbidden.  But that’s not really what this is about.  It’s not about forbidden happiness.  Saying so is selfserving, because you may have found it and maybe she has not.

It’s about doing the right thing.  The first step is talking about it.

Talking about it….that is forbidden.